In early 2020, while consulting on the Belmore Park Master Plan, Council received a proposal from a group of residents to build a community garden in Belmore Park. The site was found to pose some difficulties because of the large established trees on site.
In 2021, an opportunity arose to fund a community garden in the Dundas Ward. To take advantage of the opportunity, the Belmore Park group agreed to move to Sherwin Park and began planning the garden with assistance from Permaculture Sydney West and Council.
The creation of the Sherwin Park Community Garden was also seen as a solution to the loss of the Sorrell Lane Community Garden, which was forced to close when the privately-owned land on which it was located was sold.